Skip to Content

Your Injury Lawyers

An Indiana Personal Injury Attorney Fighting For Injured Clients For Over 50 Years

Get a Free Consultation

Contact us for Help

Schedule Consultation

Practice Areas

Our goal is to defend your rights aggressively and handle your legal and insurance claims with minimal demands on your time while you focus on your recovery. If you or a loved one have been injured in an accident, your Indiana personal injury attorney team at Tofaute & Spelman can help.

Why We Stand Out


Our firm was founded in 1969, and with over 150 years of combined experience, our clients are accustomed to receiving top-notch results—we have recovered multi-million dollar results for thousands of clients over the years.


We are a community law firm, and we care about our community. We have lived, raised our families, and worked in this community for decades. We understand what’s important to our clients and their families. 


You’re not just hiring one Indiana personal injury attorney; you’re hiring a team. Our teamwork approach encourages brainstorming and allows everyone on our team an opportunity to contribute towards achieving optimal results for you.


We understand that no two cases are the same. So we’ll adjust our strategies to fit your unique set of circumstances. Our team approach allows us to take on the kind of unconventional cases other firms are afraid to take.


Working with a smaller, more personalized firm has many benefits. One is that we are here for you 24/7/365. We understand what you are going through and that when questions arise, you need answers fast. So call us anytime; we are here for you. 


We’ll approach your case personally with flexibility, efficiency, fearlessness, and an eye always on the most important thing for you: to see your best possible outcome come to fruition. We love helping our clients win.


Our Hometown Firm Can Help Your Family

We’ve spent over 50 years helping people just like you throughout our community. When you hire one of us, you hire ALL of us. So we’ll put our entire firm at your disposal, not just one or two people. 

Over the span of 50 years, there’s not much we haven’t seen. And if we’ve seen it, we’ve already figured out a way to handle it. The Indiana personal injury attorney team from Tofaute & Spelman takes the cases that scare the big firms away. We are driven and experienced negotiators and are very familiar with the courtrooms and judges across the state.

Our primary goal is to help you put yourself and your family back together after an unfortunate circumstance that has impacted all of you.

Contact An Indiana Personal Injury Attorney at Tofaute & Spelman Right Now For Help

We offer FREE consultations, same-day return phone calls, and emails, multilingual staff, and we are available 24/7/365.

Get a Free Consultation


Most people do not fully understand how to protect themselves from predatory insurance company tactics unless they've been trained in the law. Some of the most common questions we receive from clients include:

Do I Pay You Any Money Up Front? 

Absolutely NO! Our case evaluation is FREE.

Why Should I Choose You as My Lawyer?

There are many good lawyers, we are just one firm having several lawyers who spend 99% of their practice dealing with your type of specific injuries and details.  What we do and all we do. 150 years combined experience.  We have 100 years combined experience doing so.

How Long Will My Case Take?  

That depends upon how long it takes you to recover from your injuries and whether or not you have any permanent injuries.  Your doctor (s) must release you from care.

How Do I Get My Car Fixed and Get a Rental?

The wrongdoer’s insurance company will provide a rental vehicle in some cases for a short time while your vehicle is being totaled or repaired.

How much is my case worth?

Depends upon several factors and facts of your case, most of which are not known at your first appointment; however, we are able to set case values after your medical treatment is complete.